David Hazinski calls on traditional media to regulate it’s “citizen journalism” content:
Having just anyone produce widely distributed stories without control can have the reverse effect from what advocates intend. It’s just a matter of time before something like a faked Rodney King beating video appears on the air somewhere.
Journalism organizations should head that off. Citizen reports can be a valuable addition to news and information flow with some protections:
• Major news organizations must create standards to substantiate citizen-contributed information and video, and ensure its accuracy and authenticity.
• They should clarify and reinforce their own standards and work through trade organizations to enforce national standards so they have real meaning.
• Journalism schools such as mine at the University of Georgia should create mini-courses to certify citizen journalists in proper ethics and procedures, much as volunteer teachers, paramedics and sheriff’s auxiliaries are trained and certified.
The first point should be a given. That traditional media would run with a random story fed to it by a “citizen journalist” without trying to back it up is reckless and completely erodes any confidence the public should have in that outlet.
The second point is a bit tricky as media continues to be market driven in that it’s a for-profit enterprise that relies on sucking in consumers. To do this many outlets may find themselves going out on a limb on things, using and adage that it’s better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission and correcting themselves should they screw up. Aside from that, most traditional media outlets would already assert that follow and enforce standards for their content. Having them do so yet again won’t solve anything.
The third point, while interesting and worthwhile, is another unenforceable tactic that simply attempts to turn “citizen journalists” into “journalists”. Yet courses would most appeal to those citizen journalists who are already trying to be ethical in their work and understand that there is a responsibility that comes with journalism. The splash-and-trash elements that still dominate some areas of citizen journalism would continue to do business as usual. It’s the same flaw with trying to create or enforce any Code of Ethics among bloggers: only those who are already trying to follow such a code will sign on, those who do not won’t.
Josh Wolf has more over at CNET News.